by Meghan Fitzgerald
What is Cognitive Empathy?
Sometimes called “perspective taking,” cognitive empathy (one of three types of empathy) is the ability to imagine how another person is thinking in a given situation. What mental models does the other person have? What is driving them? This capacity also enables us to communicate effectively with other people.
If you spend time around babies and toddlers, you can see that this capacity grows as the brain develops. For example, a one-year-old may soothe a friend by handing her his own favorite toy. Once he is over two, he may opt to go and get a sad friend the toy that she likes best, more able to note and respond to her emotions based on his knowledge of what would best soothe her.
How can we support cognitive empathy?
Try adding some of these nifty ways to support cognitive empathy to your family routines.
Rewrite the golden rule: Doing unto others as you would have done unto you sounds virtuous, but it’s not really empathetic at all. As our girls have grown, we’ve unpacked this with them and agreed to use the revised rule, “Do unto others as they would prefer.” This simple change has made all the difference. This new rule has given us a great starting point from which to engage in conversations that our kids can lead while we scaffold them with the chance to stop, reflect on the other person, and try to take their perspective.
“Do unto others as they would prefer.”
Support pretend play: Pretend play is the way that children learn to take different perspectives. When a child makes believe that he is a mama bird, a monster or a firefighter, he starts to explore what it must be like to be that other person or creature. Even though pretend play starts quite simple, early experiences with pretending form strong roots of perspective taking on which more sophisticated cognitive empathy can grow.
“When children pretend, they’re using their imaginations to move beyond the bounds of reality. A stick can be a magic wand. A sock can be a puppet. A small child can be a superhero.” — Fred Rogers
To serve kids and preserve our own sanity, we aim to help our children develop their own pretend play skills. This does NOT mean that we have to be our child’s constant playmate. That feeling of needing to be playmate not only adds to our stress as parents, but it is also quite the opposite of what we want to do. It’s our job to grant them the time, the environment, and the invitation to pretend. Then, we can give them the reigns and take a seat to their side, joining, observing, honor and supporting in a responsive but not a directive way.
Give kids time: Giving time requires a few agreements. First, you need to slow down and stay in one place long enough for kids to play (per research, that is 30 minutes or more). Second, kids need plenty of time for play to “catch fire,” and we have to allow their visible engagement level to rise and fall as they play. If they look “disinterested” that’s okay—lulls are part of play, and the less we intervene, the more likely they’ll learn to start, drive and revive their own play.
Give kids an environment: A play environment includes the literal setting as well as the objects and other people in that setting. Here are a few of our favorite ways to nail the environment:
When in doubt, go outdoors. Nature comes complete with inspiring places to run, hide, climb and an endless array of compelling objects that can become anything they need to be.
Include other children of varying ages. Play and learning are social endeavors, and kids learn in community. Finding great playful learning communities gives kids what they need and takes the pressure off of us too.
Bring a few items from indoors that can be used in many ways to bridge pretend play. An old bed sheet can become a cape, a cave or a boat. A bucket can become a hat, a vessel for stew, or a steel drum. Art materials can take on new dimensions outdoors.
Invite kids to play: Sometimes just the prompt to “go play” is invitation enough. We can also invite children into their own play by doing the following types of things, then stepping back and letting them run with it:
Asking “I wonder” questions, like “I wonder what you could make in an outdoor kitchen?” or “I wonder what we could use to color this white sheet?”
“Let’s pretend:” When you do have time, ask kids to pretend to be an animal that you see everyday or a creature that they absolutely love. Pretend that you are hungry and wonder how you will get food. Pretend that you are tired...where will you rest and how will you make it comfortable? Pretend you are scared, what other creatures might be around that make you need to run and hide?
Make Animal Allies: Education expert and inspiring advocate for outdoor learning, David Sobel, reminds us, “Cultivating relationships with animals, both real and imagined, is one of the best ways to foster empathy during early childhood.” Because early childhood is a time in which children do not fully differentiate self from other, reality from fantasy, it makes them particularly able to identify with animals. So pretending to be animals not only supports perspective taking, it turns animals into allies, connecting children to other species in profound and lasting ways.
Model thinking about what others are thinking without judgment. Show consistent curiosity about how others think.
As you are reading stories, ask questions like, “Why do you think she is doing that?” “What do you think he is hoping?” and “What was he thinking?!” Do this for characters who could fall in both good guy and bad guy buckets, making sure to present both in 3-D.
Be certain to do this for real people too, both children and adults. When you can, leave open the possibility that even someone who is frustrating may have reasons for acting in ways and also has wonderful qualities, valid feelings, etc.
Little kids are still learning. When a child does something that is not ideal socially, talk with our kids about how they are learning, like all of us. If you can, Include something that you admire about that child, too.
Work hard to understand bias: We all carry bias into the interactions we have with others. If we truly want to nail cognitive empathy, we need to start by reflecting on how our own experiences and identity impact how we think and act. Where do we have hidden bias?
From this place of curiosity and self-reflection, we can start to work hard to better understand how experiences and identity impact those around us and inform their thoughts, motivations and actions. This is life’s work.
Our world is not an equitable place, and aspects of identity including race, ethnicity, socioeconomic situation, nationality, and gender drastically impact the way we each experience, think and act in the world. The more we each can learn about this and start to do the work it takes to better identify the biases that block us from being able to understand where another person is coming from, the better we’ll be able to model true cognitive empathy for our kids. And, the better able we’ll be to take real action to address inequities that erode our communities.
Here are a few organizations that we admire and that are helping us with this work: